Curious to see everyone's ATF list. Just trying to compare taste overlap to get a better sense of reviews.
I tend to oscillate: the fuller / curvy types (Haven, Ellie, IV), but generally prefer more skinny / willowy types (Esme K, Katie K, Angel).
My ATFs are (in no particular order, I would consider them all S-tier):
[B]Nali:[/B] Epic service, perfect pussy and love her skinny body. Virtually no body fat. I also like her face a lot. She has a very feline, cat-like look to me. Drawback is she can't really take it doggy and she has pretty much no ass. And her MMs are not super natural feeling, but they look good (maybe a bit too big for her frame). Honestly wish she didn't have MMs. But her BBBJ is so good though, and her squirms and squeals are unparalleled.
[B]Katie K:[/B] Tiny, super skinny. Also virtually no body fat. Perfect tits for her size, with veins and perfect nipples. Pretty much shaved, but had tiny wispy hairs and I loved it. Her demeanor was the best, like a girlfriend / wife that is caring and loving. Service is great. Top tier face. I would date her IRL. Not the greatest ass, but it's not as flat as Nali.
[B]Esme K:[/B] Probably my favorite body-wise. Ballerina-esque and all-natural. Skinny. Long legs. Nice ass and hips. Perfect natural Cs with perfect puffy / inverted nipples and her pussy was full Bush (if you can call it that), but it was such a tiny little patch it was so sexy. Great English too, but maybe a little too talkative. I hope she comes back.
[B]Angel[/B] Another great ballerina-esque body (similar to Esme, but not as natural). Her face was top tier, kind of reminds me of a Korean Angelina Jolie. Service was okay though, but I did like that she had a little bit of hair down there (trimmed). Too expensive for a consistent repeat IMO, but definitely worth a try at least once.
If I could combine Nali's service with Katie K's pussy, face, and demeanor and Esme's body, and throw in a fuller ass, that would be my dream girl and I would be a broke man, but a happy man.
Rankings by attribute:
Face: [B]Katie K > Angel > Nali > Esme K[/B].
Body: [B]Esme K > Katie K > Angel > Nali[/B].
Service: [B]Nali > Katie K > Esme K > Angel[/B].
Tits: [B]Esme K (natural, which gives her the edge) >= Katie K > Angel > Nali[/B].
Pussy: [B]Katie K > Esme K >= Nali > Angel[/B].
Ass: [B]Esme K > Katie K > Angel > Nali[/B].
Honorable mentions:
Freesia is definitely S-tier in terms of looks, service, body. But for some reason I just didn't click with her. Also her pussy isn't the tightest and I think her tattoos weren't tasteful (I'm not opposed to tattoos in general). Daisy is someone I feel that people generally consider S-tier, but for me she is overrated and was A, maybe A+ at best. Still solid, but I would rather have Ina / Collette over Daisy (she scratches a similar itch for me). Ina has better service and is definitely A+ tier body / looks for me (S-tier service), really great value.
