Observations on getting SA responses
I have had a dramatic increase in the number of responses to my opening contacts with girls on SA, which I attribute to a few reasons. I'm pretty new in the bowl and still learning, and would not say I've had the greatest game with women, generally. Some of this info has also made its appearance in these threads earlier, from star senior members. Still, here may be lurkers or newbies out there who want pointers all in one place. I also don't have statistical data to back up these statements, just a general observation / sense.
My initial approach, guided by seniors, was to be the nice guy, which is pretty much my approach to women in civi life. I have a nice 3 paragraph message that fits into SAs character limit, I customize it to each profile, and I send it off. I got a pretty low hit rate. The more I read here that many SBs on SA are submissive or kinky, I decided to modify / add to this. If I don't get a reply to my initial salvo in a few days, I follow up with my kinky message, which basically says being on SA is itself adventurous, and maybe she is on it b / c she would like to interact with men in a new way (with allusions to grey or shades), and then something about being a sugar baby being a sexual taboo. In my own case, since I am married, I also put in something about being with a married man scratching her "naughty" itch. Mix and match terms to your hearts desire. It would also be possible to put this kink paragraph into an initial message for girls who indicate receptiveness in their profiles. Open-minded, etc. I am amazed at the girls who look innocent but did not reply to my nice guy message, but did come back to me when I sent the second one. They didn't necessarily respond explicitly to those parts (well, one clearly did) but they at least replied. I have also tried sending the kinky paragraph message initially, and the results are inconclusive.
The other thing is something HollywoodGuy informed me is the take-away, a sales tactic I used unwittingly. After my initial month on SA I had a SB and decided not to re-up my membership. God, its hard enough to renew your membership these days. Just before that, though, I sent a message to all of the POTs I had been interacting well with, thanking them for their messaging and making a general but suggestive statement about leaving SA (situation changed). I got a bunch of responses to that. This exact thing is happening now. My membership is lapsing in the next 24 hours, in fact I'm surprised each time I log on and it is still going. Again, everyone who I had recently been contacting got a brief message explaining I was not continuing my membership and they were the only woman on the site who could contact me (with the phone # and email I provided). I got texts and / or emails from at least 10 of these girls, some I'd been drooling over. Several incredibly hot 20 YO Latinas from inland empire; a 23 YO model / cheerleader from Long Beach (and she sent photo after photo even when I'd sent pictures of my ugly mug). Something that also hooked this girl is asking what foreign languages she speaks and if she has a passport. It implies but does not state you are considering her for travel, which some are hoping for (ignoring the contradiction to SD anonymity).
Happy bowling, gents.