How is stopping the behavior "powerless"?
How exactly is STOPPING a behavior ('compulsive" or "addictive") an example of being "powerless", if the behavior STOPS? If someone is "powerless" over ANY activity, there would NEVER be ANY STOPPING OVER IT! (like having control over blinking!). So, where exactly is any RESPONSIBILITY over a behavior taken if a "12-Step" program's assertion is you are "powerless to stop it", and yet DO! Makes no damned sense! Period!
[QUOTE=Wonderlust]Well friend, that's what is taught in a twelve step program. It doesn't matter if it's a program for AA, SA(sex addiction), eating addiction or other compulsive disorders or addictions. Recognise you are powerless over the addiction and take responsibility for your life.
I have had some good success with my sex addiction. I have not used the services of a prostitute in quite some time. I still think about it but those thoughts don't have the same power over me they once had. I do prefer to think about it as a compulsion rather than an addiction though.[/QUOTE]
Some Not-Too-Profound Ideas
Nothing too profound, but here are some ideas that I'm throwing out, FWIW.
A compulsion is a strong urge that one can overcome without significant outside help.
An addiction is a strong compulsion that one can usually only overcome with significant outside help.
It is very difficult to impossible to help someone who denies the problem and doesn't seek help.
At least in the short term, one can be "powerless" over the *feeling* to engage in certain acts, but at the same time, one has the power to resist the act itself, though maybe with great difficulty.
Different things work for different people. Humans are nothing if not extremely complex beings.
Good luck and best wishes to all.
D
Understanding and GROWING UP!
What exactly IS it that you want "Gotten"? Your inability to make RATIONAL CHOICES? What a pathetic, waste of oxygen consumption you are? Obviously, rational decision making will never be your forte! I am ecstatic about my 42, soon to be 43 years too! They involve ZERO ADDICTION OF ANY IMPAIRING BEHAVIOR OR SUBSTANCE! Don't be jealous!
[QUOTE=A John]It's OK you just don't get it! For that matter probably never will.
However don't forget opinions are like assholes everybody's got one.
I hope someday when I grow up I can be as responsible and self-righteous as others!
AJ
PS
Not that it would matter to you or that I personally care about your opinion. I am extremely ecstatic about MY 42yrs.
Never criticize a man unless you`ve walked in his shoes.
Wonderlust knows exactly where I'm coming from, and that's what was important to me![/QUOTE]
Agreement & Responsibility!
Thank you Snake! Point well taken! I too don't have withdrawls if I don't get laid, but blue balls sure hurt, and it sucks to not have that pleasure that is found in SEX! However, it does not, nor ever has been at the level of an "addiction", and for anyone advocating that it is, is well-versed in the art of NOT taking responsibility for what is an overwhelmingly VOLUNTARY activity, whether it is consuming sex or an illicit, intoxicating drug. Period!
[QUOTE=Snake27]Well, there is something to what Redneck is saying.
For example, I have never been addicted to heroin because I know it's highly addictive and I have resisted all invitations to give it a try. I am responsible for that first hit.
From what I remember reading there is some controversy in the psychology community about whether "sex addiction" even exists. And IMHO we shouldn't demand forum members produce citations of studies. Of course it would improve their credibility but this is an anonymous forum, not a peer-reviewed journal. The way it works for me is: if a credible-sounding member makes a statement which is interesting or useful to me, I'll follow-up on it myself. For example, I researched the 12-step program because of what I read here.
Indeed there is some danger that by calling a behaviour an "addiction" we dismiss our responsiblity. We may rationalize that we are no longer in control, so it's somehow ok to do it. We say: "Can't stop it, so don't try."
Hookers are just not on a par with heroin. I don't go into a shaking delirium if I have deprived myself of hookers.
I'm not trying to give anyone a hard time -- I know it's tough out there -- just playing devil's advocate here.[/QUOTE]
ACTION, not "desire" replaces an "addiction"!
One of the worst forms of mental masturbation perpetuated on American society is this belief that it is a "desire to stop" that results in one stopping an "addictive behavior". How exactly can this be, when the "desire" to stop an activity is just a THOUGHT, whereas the ACT OF STOPPING equals the actual stopping? You can think, plan, desire, contemplate, meditate, masturbate, and levitate your way all over the act of "stopping", but IT NEVER WILL OCCUR until you actually engage in the VOLUNTARY ACT OF STOPPING THE BEHAVIOR! PERIOD! Thinking about it does NOTHING. Stopping it does! THAT is the damned difference! It does not matter whether the activity is an addictive substance, or a so-called "addictive activity", until you stop it, you are only engaging in mental masturbation. You actually want it done? KNOCK IT THE HELL OFF! PERIOD!
[QUOTE=The Backrow]Over the past two years I have read everything I can get my hands on about addiction and recovery. I have come to the conclusion that it doesn't matter what recovery program is followed. I have, however, noticed 2 keys to successful recovery from an addiction. They are: 1. The person must have an overwhelming desire to change their behavior, and 2. They must believe, without a doubt, they can change their behavior. If those 2 keys are not present then no recovery program will work.
For those who want to blast my observations, feel free to do so. It won't change what I have seen.[/QUOTE]
TV Movie: "Love Sick: Secrets of a Sex Addict"
Love Sick: Secrets of a Sex AddictSynopsis:
Based on the book by Sue William Silverman, her personal account of conquering sexual addiction through therapy and a 12-step program after a life of abuse.
Genre: Drama, Adaptation
URL: [url]http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1213864/[/url]
Director:Grant Harvey
Writer:Maria Nation (writer)
Release Date:19 April 2008 (USA) more
Genre:Biography | Drama more
Plot:Based on a memoir by Sue William Silverman about her struggle and triumph over sexual addiction. | add synopsis
Plot Keywords:Seedy Motel | Sex Addict | Partial Female Nudity | Motel Sex | Twelve Step Program
User Comments:I expected more.
*** This comment may contain spoilers ***
I expected there to be more sex scenes in a movie about sex. I didn't need to see nudity or certain body parts but I thought that the scenes they showed were way too short. I had to wait 41 minutes into the movie just to see a two minute scene of lust. It wasn't enough for me watching Sue clean her house and serve cake. I didn't watch the movie for that, I wanted what the title gave me. I suppose I shouldn't judge a movie by it's title. Especially not this movie. There were some good things in it too like how she opened up to her psychiatrist about her past. It explained a lot about the movie. I really didn't know if she was addicted to sex, I thought that she just had a sex problem but what do I know. I really expected more out of this movie and I was somewhat disappointed.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cast (Cast overview, first billed only)
Sally Pressman ... Sue Silverman
Actress:
"Army Wives" .... Roxy LeBlanc / ... (25 episodes, 2007-2008)
- Episode #2.5 (2008) TV episode .... Roxy LeBlanc
- The Messenger (2008) TV episode .... Roxy LeBlanc
- Strangers in a Strange Land (2008) TV episode .... Roxy LeBlanc
- Would You Know My Name (2008) TV episode .... Roxy LeBlanc
- Goodbye Stranger (2007) TV episode .... Roxy LeBlanc
(20 more)
Love Sick: Secrets of a Sex Addict (2008) (TV) .... Sue Silverman
"The New Adventures of Old Christine" .... Melanie (1 episode, 2008)
- Between a Rock and a Hard Place (2008) TV episode .... Melanie
"Criminal Minds" .... Chrissy Wilkinson (1 episode, 2007)
- Birthright (2007) TV episode .... Chrissy Wilkinson
Life Unkind (2007) .... Amelia
The Dread (2007) .... Teri
Last Rites of the Dead (2006) .... Angela's Boss
... aka Last Rites of the Dead (USA: copyright title)
... aka Zombies Anonymous (USA: new title)
"Shark" .... Deena Brock (1 episode, 2006)
- Pilot (2006) TV episode .... Deena Brock